Entry 4:
Argument structures and fallacies
Item :
“ Nếu Thượng Đế làm gì cũng được, thì Thượng Đế có thể làm ra 1 cục đá nặng đến chính Ngài cũng không nâng nổi”
Analysis :
The appeal to power : the God can do everthing
False premises ; two premises is contradictory. if God can do everything, he can create anything including a rock that he can not lift. It is opposite to what said above that God can do everthing.
hi, Nhung! I think you should analyse the argument structure first to find argument fallacy. However, I find your item confusing and I don't understand the conclusion of this saying, it is "God can do everything " or "God can't do everything"
Trả lờiXóaI hope you can make your analysis clearer :D
Nhận xét này đã bị tác giả xóa.
Trả lờiXóaHi Nhung
Trả lờiXóaI have just looked on your entry and I would like to leave some comment:
Your item is a bit simple, I hope you will choose another one which is more interesting. In addition, you have never analysed the argument strucyure before leading to argument fallacy
Moreover, it’s not easy for people who read your task to understand.
Anyway, thanks your entry very much!!!!!
2 Nhung!
Trả lờiXóaWhere did you get your item? i don't see any source here
I don't understand your analysis.I see that you point out two premises:God can do everything, he can create anything including a rock that he can not lift.However,you also suppose that the conclusion is"God can do everthing."In my opinion.there is only one premise:God can do every thing,and the conclusion:he can create anything including a rock that he can not lift.They are oposite to each other.
Trả lờiXóaI think it is much better when you find a concrete situation to analyse.
Anyway,thank you very much for your entry.
dear Nhung
Trả lờiXóai want give you some comments
first, you should point out what kind of argument's error
second, make your analysis clearer.
lastly, where is its source?
Hi,
Trả lờiXóaFirst of all, where is the source of your entry>
Second, you should point out the premises and conclusion
Thanks for ur entry!