Thứ Sáu, 25 tháng 11, 2011

Entry 4_Dương Thị Hồng Ngát

Item 1:
Gà có hai chân
Vịt có hai chân
=> Gà là Vịt

Analyze: False conclusion. Many genders have many common characteristics but no one can affirm the chicken specied is duck specied because they all have two legs.

Source: Logical exercise from Miss Hong Dieu - logical professor

4 nhận xét:

  1. hi Ngat,
    I think you should give more detailed analysis. In my opinion, this is an invalid argument because of structural fallacies

    Trả lờiXóa
  2. Hi Ngat
    I have just looked on your entry and I would like to leave some comment
    Your item is a bit simple, I hope you will choose another one which is more interesting. In addition, you did not point out what is the argument error, ( I mean the name of error) I think it is invalid argument .
    You should explain more because it’s not easy for people who read your task to understand .
    Anyway, thanks your entry very much!!!!!

    Trả lờiXóa
  3. I agree with Thuy’ that you should point out what is the argument error, and choose a more complicated to analyse. I think that this argument is valid, but unsound & worthless argument.

    Trả lờiXóa
  4. Thank for your comments. I'm sorry for my carelessness

    Trả lờiXóa